« The DoFuss Show – Call of Duty vs. Halo, EXTREME!!!!!!!!!!! 
 I Got Me an iPhone. »

Continuing the Movie Metaphors – Systems’ Markets.

July 22nd, 2009 Posted by Alex Beech

This console generation has seen a divergence in style for each platform’s exclusive titles. All three home systems have carved out a segment of the market and audience of their own by virtue of this. To revisit elements of my last post, each system’s niche could be best compared to movie genres.

Admit it, you want to see the Mario Pixar movie.

Admit it, you want to see the Mario Pixar movie.

The first and maybe the most obvious is the Wii that occupies a space similar to that of the family movie. Mario could sit happily next to Toy Story and Zelda snuggle next to The Princess Bride. While the system is renowned for its kid friendly image, when put in the context of the movies the power of this becomes apparent. Like a Pixar movie Wii offers entertainment that any audience can enjoy. It offers games that are entertaining on a number of levels and free from inappropriate content. Maybe some would prefer other titles, or kick up some meaningless fuss based on preconception of childishness, but if the audience would let themselves then the games offer simple fun.
.

I suspect more Colony Marines would have made it off LV-426 if Mater Chief had been there.

I suspect more Colony Marines would have made it off LV-426 if Mater Chief had been there.

Every system has games that could be described as blockbusters, but the dominance of the 360 in this field is unmatched. The Halos and Gears of War (GoW) are comparable to Aliens, Starship Troopers or if you want something more contemporary (philistines) Transformers. These are games and movies that I can enjoy regularly. Not a year goes by that I don’t revisit some of these games and movies but they are not titles that I feel a deep attachment to. They are fun, mindless and throw away experiences. Do not misunderstand me; these are among my favorite entertainment experiences. I just mean they do not challenge the audience, and rarely inspire further thought or discussion. They are pure escapism and provide mindless, frenetic fun.

Malkovich, Malkovich, Malkovich - Yeah, I got nothing.

Malkovich, Malkovich, Malkovich - Yeah, I got nothing.

Finally comes the more art house domain of the PS3, movies and games that engage the audience on a deeper level than their peers. While entertaining these titles manage to introduce questions and initiate more discussion. Being John Malkovich may not at first glance seem to have much in common with Metal Gear Solid 4, but the level of engagement required and the questions they force the audience to consider are distinctly weightier that of their contemporaries. The result of this is that the audience is affected more deeply than the explosion heavy blockbuster style offerings, but they are less eagerly revisited. I would be happy to revisit GoW, but MGS will stay firmly on my shelf kept more for nostalgia than any practical use. The after discussion is where the entertainment lies for me now in these titles.

Of course this is painting in very broad strokes, focusing on each system key titles (and the perception of each system). Now with the market being considerably more diluted than in previous generations, with fewer exclusives eventually nearly every game will find its way onto your system of choice (assuming the Wii isn’t your only option). Thinking back to the 16-bit era your choice of system would heavily dictate your library. Now though it is only the first party published (with a few rare third party exceptions) which limit player’s selection. This relative freedom is liberating for gamers, assuming that players pick their system wisely based on their interest in the exclusive titles.

TwitterGoogle BookmarksDeliciousDiggLinkedInGoogle ReaderShare

Tags: 360, Movies, PS3, Wii
Add a Comment Trackback

4 Comments

  1. Kam
    July 23rd, 2009 at 4:44 am

    Where’s the psychobabble?

  2. alex
    July 23rd, 2009 at 8:04 am

    Was tempted to add at the end that if they don’t choose their system wisely they may engage in cognitive dissidence, but I settled on a veiled Last Crusade reference.

  3. feitclub
    July 23rd, 2009 at 4:21 pm

    Never thought about it like this before. It makes sense when you factor in the experimental stuff on PSN these days – Flower, Noby Noby BOY, PixelJunk’s stuff. But as you point out, there’s an increasing number of multiplatform games now.

    Perhaps Xbox and PS3 could be compared to major movie studios who try to have it all (action, comedy, drama, indie) while the Nintendo as Disney metaphor stands. Disney makes other kinds of pictures too, but they hide them behind an alternate name (i.e. Touchstone) to keep the Disney name associated with family friendly fare.

  4. Darren DoFuss
    July 24th, 2009 at 9:22 pm

    Someone just said ‘cognitive dissidence’ on the radio. I submit to your throbbing, all-knowing brain Al.
    -

Add a Comment

  • DoFuss Games Discussion and Culture
    Games Discussion and Culture
  • Search DoFuss

  • Contact us at:

    Alex - alex[at]dofuss[dot]net

    Darren - darren[at]dofuss[dot]net

  • DoFuss Radio

  • [Valid RSS] subscribe to the podcast
    DoFuss Radio Download Page
  • Recent Comments

    • PS4 ISO on DoFuss 2010 – The Further Chronicles
    • Alex Beech on (The Final Late) Gamescom Catch Up – Getting Down To It.
    • Ahm on (The Final Late) Gamescom Catch Up – Getting Down To It.
    • Alex Beech on (The Final Late) Gamescom Catch Up – Getting Down To It.
    • Ahm on (The Final Late) Gamescom Catch Up – Getting Down To It.
  • More DoFuss

    • Game People
    • Games Jobs Japan
    • Play Devil
  • Our Affiliates

    • Feitclub
    • Original Gamer
    • Sudo Gamer
    • TGSN.co.uk
    • UUDDLRLRBA Forums
    • Xboxer 360
  • Gamepeople News

    • The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing XBLA News || Reporting Gamer column on Game People
    • Guild Wars 2 PC News || Reporting Gamer column on Game People
    • Hybrid XBLA News || Reporting Gamer column on Game People
    • Miner Wars 2081 360 News || Reporting Gamer column on Game People
    • Bang Bang Racing PS3 PSN News || Reporting Gamer column on Game People
  • Scared DoFuss

    • Fez 360 Review || Scared Gamer column on Game People
    • Catherine 360 Review || Scared Gamer column on Game People
    • Journey PS3 PSN Review || Scared Gamer column on Game People
    • Scary Girl XBLA Review || Scared Gamer column on Game People